The buffer is not a fudge factor. It is a named allowance for things that have already gone wrong on other people's rooms: a torn drop on first hang, a measurement off by an inch, the offcuts around outlets and switches, and the drop wasted learning how the paste cures on your specific wall texture.
Default 10% for no-match or straight-match on smooth drywall. Bump to 15% for half-drop, untrimmed paper, paste-the-wall installs, or out-of-plumb corners. Push to 18–20% for stairwells, curved walls, or any install where you can't reuse a half drop. The buffer is a slider, not a fixed line, because the right number depends on which branches you took above it.
Q: Should I order one extra roll on top of the buffer? Only if the design is discontinued or the retailer won't return opened batches. The buffer already absorbs a torn drop; one extra roll is belt-and-suspenders.
Q: Why does the same room return different totals on different calculators? Usually because one ignored the pattern repeat, treated the room as a single rectangle, or rounded at the wrong step. The branches above are where the disagreement lives.